BAKE SHOP ORDERS

ICC BAKE SHOP featured in both ITHACA COFFEE COMPANY Cafés
Bake Shop Header

What Sets Our Baked Goods Apart?

First, everything you taste was freshly-baked that day, whether delivered ready-to-serve from our bake shop or baked off right there in our cafés. We provide the freshest goods possible. Everything is made from scratch using only high quality ingredients, like real all-butter doughs and never any added preservatives. We pay great attention to taste, texture, and presentation as we experiment with fun seasonal specials. We're always innovating so that we can continue to create something tasty and new for you to try each time you stop by.

Below you can scroll through a gallery with some examples of the seasonal and regularly created goods crafted by our bakery:


Linzer Cookie

Molasses Cookie

Porter Bundt Cake

Brown Butter pumpkin Seed Cookie

Pumpkin Bundt Cake

Raspberry Muffin made with gluten free ingredients

Buttermilk Biscuit

Half Moon Cookie

Banana Muffin made with gluten free ingredients

Chocolate Shortbread with Salted Caramel

Lavender Shortbread

Lemon Curd Cupcake

Chocolate Ganache Filled Macaroon

Cinnamon Chip Scone

Xxx Chocolate Cookie

Cranberry Crumble Muffin

Peanut Butter Crisp Cookie

Salted Rosemary Shortbread

Blueberry Coffee Cake

House Cookie: Oatmeal Pecan Chocolate Chip

Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie

Catering Options for Meetings or Events

To make ordering easy, you will find a selection of our most popular catering items below. You can order these right here on our website and we do offer local delivery options. If the below selections don't quite fit your need, we are happy to work with you to customize a specific package. Simply contact catering@ithacacoffee.com with your request. If you are hosting an event that involves needs beyond just catering such as gift baskets or wine please visit our Event Planning page to submit a request.

In-store pickup or local delivery only. All bake shop orders require 48 hours notice. Local delivery available Mon. through Sat., 8am to 1:30pm.